Posts tagged "Hardin"

Commonwealth v. Hardin (Lawyers Weekly No. 10-185-16)

NOTICE:  All slip opinions and orders are subject to formal revision and are superseded by the advance sheets and bound volumes of the Official Reports.  If you find a typographical error or other formal error, please notify the Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Judicial Court, John Adams Courthouse, 1 Pemberton Square, Suite 2500, Boston, MA, 02108-1750; (617) 557-1030; SJCReporter@sjc.state.ma.us   SJC-12067   COMMONWEALTH  vs.  JAMES C. HARDIN.     December 6, 2016.     Breaking and Entering.  Larceny.  Practice, Criminal, Complaint, Dismissal, Appeal by Commonwealth.  Jurisdiction, Felony.     In a four-count complaint, James C. Hardin was charged with (1) malicious destruction of property having a value over $ 250, (2) breaking and entering a motor vehicle in the daytime with intent to commit a felony, (3) larceny of property having a value of $ 250 or less, and (4) possession of a class B controlled substance.  A judge in the Boston Municipal Court accepted Hardin’s guilty plea as to counts 1 and 4, charging malicious destruction and drug possession, and dismissed counts 2 and 3, charging breaking and entering and larceny, for lack of probable cause.  The Commonwealth appealed.  In a divided opinion, the Appeals Court reversed the dismissal of these counts.  Commonwealth v. Hardin, 88 Mass. App. Ct. 681 (2015).  We allowed Hardin’s application for further appellate review.  We agree that these counts of the complaint should be reinstated, but on grounds different from those relied on by the Appeals Court.   As he did before the Appeals Court, Hardin concedes that probable cause existed to support the two counts at issue.  He argues, however, that the dismissal should be affirmed on alternative grounds.  See, e.g., Commonwealth v. Va Meng Joe, 425 Mass. 99, 102 (1997) (“[a]n appellate court is free to affirm a ruling on grounds different from those relied on by the [plea] judge if the correct or preferred basis for affirmance is supported by the record”).  Specifically, Hardin argues that the challenged counts of the complaint failed to allege a cognizable criminal act and that the breaking and entering count failed to allege an essential element of the offense, namely, that Hardin broke and entered into the motor vehicle of another person.  Instead, the complaint alleges that he “did . . . break and enter a . . . motor vehicle . . . , the property of Known to Commonwealth.”[1]  Hardin’s argument that the complaint fails to state a crime raises an issue of subject matter jurisdiction, which may be raised at any time, Commonwealth v. Cantres, 405 Mass. 238, 239-240 (1989), and which cannot be waived.  Commonwealth v. Canty, 466 Mass. 535, 547 (2013), citing Commonwealth v. Palladino, 358 Mass. 28, 31 (1970).  It is the court’s duty […]

Read more...

Posted by Massachusetts Legal Resources - December 7, 2016 at 8:48 am

Categories: News   Tags: , , , ,

Commonwealth v. Hardin (Lawyers Weekly No. 11-182-15)

NOTICE:  All slip opinions and orders are subject to formal revision and are superseded by the advance sheets and bound volumes of the Official Reports.  If you find a typographical error or other formal error, please notify the Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Judicial Court, John Adams Courthouse, 1 Pemberton Square, Suite 2500, Boston, MA, 02108-1750; (617) 557-1030; SJCReporter@sjc.state.ma.us   14-P-1470                                       Appeals Court   COMMONWEALTH  vs.  JAMES C. HARDIN. No. 14-P-1470. Suffolk.     September 10, 2015. – December 7, 2015.   Present:  Green, Rubin, & Hanlon, JJ.   Breaking and Entering.  Larceny.  Practice, Criminal, Complaint, Dismissal, Appeal by Commonwealth.  Jurisdiction.     Complaint received and sworn to in the Roxbury Division of the Boston Municipal Court Department on March 19, 2014.   Dismissal of two counts of the complaint was ordered by Franco J. Gobourne, J.     Zachary Hillman, Assistant District Attorney, for the Commonwealth. Timothy St. Lawrence for the defendant.      GREEN, J.  The Commonwealth and the defendant agree that the grounds on which a judge of the Boston Municipal Court dismissed two counts of the complaint against the defendant were invalid.[1]  The defendant nonetheless contends that the dismissal should be affirmed, based on his claim (raised for the first time in his appellate brief) that the complaint was deficient on its face.  To be specific, the defendant observes that the complaint failed to specify that the vehicles into which the defendant broke and entered, and the property he stole, were owned by someone other than the defendant.[2]  Since an element of the crime of breaking and entering is that the defendant broke into property “owned by someone other than the defendant,” Commonwealth v. Kalinowski, 360 Mass. 682, 684 (1971), and an element of the crime of larceny is that “the property stolen must be ‘the property of another,’” Commonwealth v. Souza, 397 Mass. 236, 238 (1986), quoting from G. L. c. 266, § 30(1) (1984 ed.), the defendant suggests that the order of dismissal was appropriate.  We decline to affirm dismissal on the alternative ground now raised by the defendant, and remand the matter to the Boston Municipal Court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. To be sure, “[a]n appellate court is free to affirm a ruling on grounds different from those relied on by the [trial court] judge if the correct or preferred basis for affirmance is supported by the record.”  Commonwealth v. Va Meng Joe, 425 Mass. 99, 102 (1997).  However, we are not required to do so, and we decline in the present circumstances to exercise our discretion to consider in the first instance the alternative ground now suggested by the defendant.  Put simply, we see no benefit in the interest either of justice or of judicial economy […]

Read more...

Posted by Massachusetts Legal Resources - December 7, 2015 at 4:31 pm

Categories: News   Tags: , , , ,

tamoxwhere.com metalrockmusicpodcast.com techwebwolf.com mitchellscoffeetime.com 4n10store.com crayphoto.com registeredpuppiess.com leafbosscbd.com salonuniqat.com alphaproject-skiteam.com indimembrane.com escuelamasquemarketing.com chicagocityscusl.com helpweightoff.com shinylive.net fullbodychiro.net haxcommunity.org kursovaya.org theinvincibles.org aspekindonesia.org alphabiocbd.org javabluetooth.org veadotrading.com chrisamentas.com tattooartpedia.com vj0shii.info novels80.net sportinggoodindoor.net vinnysvinylsidinggreensboronc.com viewfrombangladesh.com pipiproductions.com alikhwaneplatre.com sslabs.info expressaktiv.info artistvisual.com cepatmasuk.com urutrain.com villasatmontanavista.org gularavincent.com pantaufilm.com dramabarat.com fotominsk.com kedaibilal.com martaloptiklens.com kamielis.com hariberry.com cateringmarketsquare.com nobleinternationalhotel.com erdemliotokiralama.com persongolf.com arsipskripsi.com jamesmalvern.com cryptomarketbd.com sehriart.com mrofficialonline.com roberthomestaging.com ennzcoupon.com authentik-immo.com distribuidoraconnect.com dreamydrawdesign.com muwilp.com nationalbattleleague.com maverickgrowshop.com sinansplace.com globalstreetfoods.com rollsroc.com conforthogarok.com christmastreedresses.com thetechlives.com borisvolfman.com roninindonesia.com nokritalash.com perfecthomeworkhelp.com orimeili.com elektrikci06.com toolzsource.com wellfedcreatives.com achomeandgarden.com brawnywriter.com petsfoodio.com tropisgarden.com belibibitikanmurah.com khabarbot.com goraah.com baudara.com sengelsted.com campingelrefugio.comwp-admin frankkelsoauthor.com reutovstudio.comwp-admin hunterbelgium.com terrabloggers.com tcirelocations.com parfoiswebshop.com ovofrance.com brooksmagyarorszaghu.com stilkostum.com stephenoney.com whimsypk.com sdnjunrejo1batu.com ibaethiopia.com yashikaresort.com terangindonesia.org mobilhondabogor.com patibannister.com mentaridunia.org irishadam.com davidallanhamilton.com teknik-mesin.com solarahail.com nukeradio.com stpetersmp.org shanala.com brixtonatwood.com itotecobag.com cricketlinesguru.com ioguardoilmare.com eldridgehometeam.com ngoomelarab.com birracapri.com srilankaescapes.com ranchoaromadelmar.com zamzamestates.com laluna-gard.com batunisanprasasti.com pabrikpipa.com suarasragen.com pleinairsocial.com kacafilmyogyakarta.com berasenak.com sampaiakhir.com criticalpointtheatre.com mybounceworld.comwp narinnakliyat.com charlottehornetsclub.com raahitrekkers.com verdantgardenia.com balonjakartaku.com jasabikinjersey.com tokocipta.com medicaltimes.org puertoricolimpio.org ingoodcowellness.com papisolutions.com greekgirlbeauty.com alexanderrarebooks.com watertreefulshear.com demorrosconel20.com boardgamesoftheworld.com bigscreenlab.com foundationsystemsrepair.com surveyinfoz.com juebejue.com tickedit.com rabbikushner.org bossdroid.org lepanierdegermaine.org gospelpage.net paucek.net storiyoh.com cacciamotorworx.com canceltimesharenow.travel cinediscount.com daubandbauble.com davefilms.us egy-greek.com f-1asp.com gazettemailrealestate.com greylogic.uswp-admin heirhunters-association.org.uk hf-emu.com inuyasha.us iqsoft.co.in istitutopertini.net justanotherlovestory.com lemondedeslions.com lowvisionary.com machupicchutours.travel maicoakiba.com naruto-pictures.us net9k.com pondok.app quazar-millenium.net slotonlinepgcasino.com techtv101.com thechronicleindia.com thekantaloupe.com tonyperkinsshow.com tuberadioforum.com vcsdk9.org videoprosys.com whytheyhate.us yeezystatic.org airstrike.co.za drsindi.co.za aeroklub-liberec.cz istob.cz double-aye.com uscreativebooks.com livingcolorut.com eaglepressurewasherservice.com electroauthor.com iowansformiller.com rainycamping.com expectthegreatutah.com what-is-bpm.com bniembarcadero.com coldcutsproductions.com latestcouponportal.com parentingplus.org calvinluo.us hop-cast.com goteammaria.com newproductivity.org 100randomtasks.com firstbaptistchurchchillicothe.com free-itv.com jointcontact.com natural-body.org valleyscene.com centralfloridaconcierge.org couchslobs.com iplaysims.com woollenhulls.com autourdemusil.net bradgrace.com czech100.com jetharrismemorialfund.org abunchofcrock.com americanmugandsteincompany.com quenchsa.com byrunners.com sharkberg.com