A judge refused on Thursday, November 19, 2026, to send Aidan Kearney, the Massachusetts blogger known as Turtleboy, back to jail before his witness intimidation trial. Judge Christopher Belezos denied the special prosecutor’s motion to revoke Kearney’s bail but added a new condition of release, WCVB and Boston.com reported. The trial, which had been set for December 7, will now start in February 2027.
That timing matters to the defense. By February, Norfolk County will have a new district attorney, and Kearney’s lawyer said he hopes she drops the case.
Kearney has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.
What happened in court
- Bail stays in place. Special prosecutor Robert Cosgrove asked the judge to revoke Kearney’s bail. The request rested on allegations that Kearney leaked impounded phone records belonging to Jennifer McCabe, a prosecution witness in the Karen Read case, Boston.com reported. Belezos declined.
- A new condition. Belezos amended Kearney’s conditions of release to bar him from publishing, broadcasting or publicly addressing any materials that are impounded or protected by court order, according to Boston.com. WCVB described the new condition the same way. “What the rest of the world does, the rest of the world does,” the judge added, Boston.com reported.
- The defense response. Defense attorney Tim Bradl argued Kearney was not relying on impounded documents for his livestreams and that McCabe’s text messages were already in the public domain, Boston.com reported. Cosgrove had alleged Kearney shared impounded material with a former partner who posted the records online after their breakup. We are not naming that person.
- A new trial date. The trial was moved to February 1, with a pretrial hearing January 15, WCVB reported. The judge ordered both sides to submit witness lists by January 4.
- Where it will be tried. WCVB reported that jurors will be drawn from Norfolk County but the trial will be held at Suffolk Superior Court.
Why the defense wants the delay
“I want to hear from her about the First Amendment,” Bradl said, according to WCVB, referring to Norfolk District Attorney-elect Djuna Perkins. “Aidan wants to know, ‘What is the rule in Norfolk County? Who is going to be the next journalist if she doesn’t speak out?'”
Perkins did not commit either way. “When I assume the role of District Attorney in January, my office will review the evidence in the Aidan Kearney matters as it will in every case,” she said, as quoted by WCVB.
There is a wrinkle. The case is being prosecuted by a special prosecutor, Cosgrove, not by the district attorney’s own staff. Neither outlet reported how a change in district attorney would affect his appointment or who would decide whether to keep the case going. Perkins’s statement says her office will review it.
The charges
Kearney’s witness intimidation charges are spread across two Norfolk Superior Court cases that will be tried together, Boston.com reported. WCVB reported that he was arrested and later indicted on 16 counts in 2023, and that court records show six of those counts were dismissed in 2025.
The charges arise from his coverage of the Karen Read case. WCVB reported that the case centers on incidents including Kearney’s alleged visit to a sporting event for McCabe’s child and to a pizza shop owned by a member of the Albert family while the Read trial was going on. Prosecutors say his aggressive questioning amounts to witness intimidation. His lawyers say he is an investigative journalist who was asking questions, and that his actions were “time-honored journalistic tactics” protected by the First Amendment, according to Boston.com.
What the law says
Witness intimidation is G.L. c. 268, § 13B. It covers anyone who willfully, directly or indirectly, “misleads, intimidates or harasses” a witness or potential witness, or a family member of one, among others, “with the intent to or with reckless disregard for the fact that it may” impede, obstruct, delay, prevent or otherwise interfere with a criminal investigation, a grand jury, a trial or another criminal proceeding.
The statute defines “harass” as an act directed at a specific person “that seriously alarms or annoys such person” and “would cause a reasonable person” to “suffer substantial emotional distress.” It expressly includes acts done by phone, email and internet communications.
That definition is where the First Amendment fight sits. The defense says questioning witnesses and reporting on them is journalism. The prosecution says the way Kearney did it crossed into conduct the statute punishes. A jury will decide, if the case gets that far.
The other cases
- The defamation lawsuit. Kearney and Read are both defendants in a lawsuit filed this year by McCabe and other witnesses, who accuse them of a “multi-year conspiracy” to defame and “torment” them, Boston.com reported.
- The case that was dropped. A third criminal case, involving an alleged altercation with an ex-girlfriend, led to about two months in jail after his bail was revoked in December 2023. Prosecutors dropped those charges last year, Boston.com reported.
- Karen Read. Read was acquitted of murder in the death of Boston police officer John O’Keefe at her second trial and convicted of drunk driving. WCVB reported it is not yet known whether she or others from that case will testify at Kearney’s trial.
Frequently asked questions
Is Turtleboy going back to jail?
No. On November 19, 2026, Judge Christopher Belezos denied the special prosecutor’s motion to revoke Aidan Kearney’s bail and added a condition barring him from publicizing impounded or protected materials, WCVB and Boston.com reported.
When is the Turtleboy trial?
February 2027. WCVB reported the date as February 1, with a pretrial hearing January 15.
Will the new Norfolk DA drop the Turtleboy case?
She hasn’t said. District Attorney-elect Djuna Perkins said her office will review the evidence “as it will in every case” when she takes office in January, according to WCVB.
What is the penalty for witness intimidation in Massachusetts?
Under G.L. c. 268, § 13B, up to 10 years in state prison or up to two and a half years in a house of correction, a fine of $1,000 to $5,000, or both. A higher penalty applies when the underlying proceeding involves a crime punishable by life in prison.
Sources: WCVB and Boston.com, November 19, 2026; G.L. c. 268, § 13B as published by the Massachusetts Legislature. General information, not legal advice.
