Sandra Birchmore and Matthew Farwell: The Federal Trial, the Charges, the Evidence Fight, and Every Date

The standing record of United States v. Farwell: the grooming allegations, why a Canton death is a federal case, the strangulation experts the defense wants excluded, and the calendar through jury selection on October 5.

Update, November 18, 2026.

Update, November 18, 2026. A juror who voted to convict Farwell told WCVB in an interview that he went into deliberations undecided on both counts and told the other jurors, “I just need you to prove to me she didn’t kill herself.” He said no single piece of evidence decided it, pointing to the timeline, the testimony about the seated position and the hyoid fracture, and a mark on Birchmore’s chest that he said jurors “focused so much on.” He asked WCVB to keep him anonymous, and we do not name any juror.

Update, November 14, 2026. Chief U.S. District Judge Denise Casper allowed the defense request on Friday, November 13, but set a fixed date instead of 30 days after transcripts. After conferring with the court reporters, she ordered Matthew Farwell’s Rule 29 and Rule 33 motion and memorandum due January 8, 2027, and the government’s response due January 22, 2027, according to the electronic order on the court docket. Sentencing remains set for February 3, 2027. What Rules 29 and 33 do.

Update, November 12, 2026.

Update, November 12, 2026. Farwell’s lawyers asked for 30 days after final transcripts to file motions for acquittal and a new trial (docket entry 405, a consent motion), and Judge Casper ordered that jurors’ names and towns may be released on written request no earlier than November 17 (docket entry 403). What the filings say.

Update, November 12, 2026.

Update, November 12, 2026. Dr. Bill Smock, a strangulation expert who testified for the prosecution, urged state law enforcement on Wednesday to rethink how death investigations are handled, the Boston Globe reported. He called for better training to detect possible strangulation or suffocation in unattended deaths, and for a specific protocol for suspicious deaths when the person who died was in an intimate relationship with a law enforcement officer, which he likened to how police shootings are investigated, according to the Globe.

Update, November 12, 2026. Incoming Norfolk DA Djuna Perkins says she will open a grand jury investigation after the Farwell verdict. Read what she said, the crimes she named, and the six-year Massachusetts deadline.

Update, November 11, 2026. Sentencing is set for February 3, 2027, Boston 25 News reported; WCVB also reported February 3 and NBC10 said early February. The verdict form, which WCVB published, asked only guilty or not guilty on each count and did not ask jurors to choose a degree of murder. The Norfolk District Attorney’s Office said in a statement that its ability to prosecute had been “constrained” by the medical examiner’s suicide finding, NBC10 reported. Read what the U.S. Attorney said at the news conference, and the question she would not answer.

Update, November 10, 2026. The U.S. Attorney. At a news conference after the verdict, U.S. Attorney Leah Foley said Farwell should have been a trusted figure in Birchmore’s life through the Stoughton police Explorers program but “wasted no time beginning to groom Sandra,” NBC10 Boston reported. When Birchmore wanted to “start a new chapter in her life,” Foley said, Farwell “feared she would tell others that he had sex with her while she was underage.” “Farwell was boxed into a corner. He needed to silence Sandra in order to keep his crimes from coming to light,” Foley said, according to NBC10.

Update, November 10, 2026. Farwell will be sentenced on February 3, WCVB reported.

Update, November 10, 2026. How the government won: never charged with murder, not the baby’s father, guilty anyway.

Update, November 10, 2026. Verdict: guilty on both counts. A federal jury convicted Matthew Farwell on November 10, 2026, of killing Sandra Birchmore and of causing the death of her unborn child, Boston 25 News and WCVB reported. The verdict came less than a day after jurors said they were deadlocked. Full story: Matthew Farwell found guilty.

Update, November 10, 2026. Jurors resumed deliberating Tuesday morning without an Allen charge. Judge Casper told them to take the time they need and that they can return day to day, NBC10 Boston reported. Latest: Farwell judge holds off on the dynamite charge.

Update, November 9, 2026. Judge Casper said Monday she was inclined to bring jurors back without further instructions and that “I don’t think it’s been so long in my estimation,” Boston.com reported. Our analysis: what Casper is likely to do Tuesday.

Update, November 9, 2026. Jurors return at 9 a.m. Tuesday, and the defense asked for an 8:30 a.m. meeting on further instructions, NBC10 reported. Former Attorney General Martha Coakley told WCVB the judge will most likely give an Allen charge. Our explainer covers what an Allen charge is and what the First Circuit requires it to say.

Update, November 9, 2026.

The jury sent Judge Casper a note Monday afternoon, November 9, saying it was “in a deadlock that looks like it will not change any time soon,” WCVB reported; NBC10 Boston also reported the deadlock note. The judge sent jurors home and told them to return Tuesday. No mistrial has been declared. What the judge can do next.

Update, November 9, 2026.

The jury of eight men and four women returned to deliberations Monday morning, November 9, after deliberating just over three hours on Friday, The Boston Globe reported. There is no verdict yet. The four alternates are two men and two women, the Globe reported.

Update, November 8, 2026.

The jury resumes deliberations at 9 a.m. Monday, November 9. Our guide to what to expect Monday, what a hung jury or mistrial would mean, and how federal jury duty works explains the possible outcomes.

Update, November 7, 2026. No verdict Friday. The jury of eight men and four women resumes deliberations at 9 a.m. Monday, November 9, WBUR and 7News reported. What each side told the jury.

Update, November 6, 2026.

Update, November 6, 2026. The jury of eight men and four women began deliberating shortly before 2:30 p.m. Friday after closing arguments, NBC10 Boston and Boston 25 News reported. Prosecutor Brian Fogerty told jurors Farwell went to Birchmore’s apartment “to save himself” (WCVB); defense attorney Kimberly Stevens pointed to the medical examiner’s original suicide ruling (NBC10). Judge Casper denied a renewed defense motion for acquittal. If there is no verdict Friday, deliberations run 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. next week. What each side argued.

Update, November 5, 2026.

Update, 10:20 a.m., November 5. Closing arguments begin around 10 a.m. Friday with the prosecution, NBC10 Boston reported, and the judge will then instruct the jury before deliberations. How closings work and what the jury must decide.

Update, November 5, 2026.

Update, November 5. No jury today; the judge is reviewing exhibits with both sides. Closing arguments are set for Friday, November 6. Our recap of the final day of testimony, when the defense rested without Farwell testifying.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 5:05 p.m., November 4. The defense rests. Farwell’s defense rested its case shortly before 5 p.m. Wednesday, after the testimony of pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew, Boston 25 News reported. Farwell did not testify. The jury is off Thursday, when the judge will go over exhibits with the lawyers, and closing arguments are expected Friday, November 6: 75 minutes for the prosecution, 90 for the defense and 15 for the prosecution’s rebuttal, NBC10 Boston reported. Deliberations are expected to follow. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 5 p.m., November 4. WHDH reported that on cross-examination, prosecutors had digital forensics expert Daniel Loper confirm there was no suicide note and no goodbye messages to friends on Birchmore’s phone on the day she died. WHDH quoted Farwell’s answer to the judge as, “At this time I do not elect to testify,” a third slightly different version of his words among the outlets covering the trial. WHDH placed Birchmore’s “suicide ribbon” search at 7:50 p.m.; NBC10 reported it at 7:50 a.m. on February 1, 2021. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 4:20 p.m., November 4. The prosecution’s cross-examination of Dr. Andrew was “very testy, almost an argument,” NBC10 Boston reported. Andrew acknowledged he was paid by Farwell’s defense team for one report, and that his report says he would certify the manner of death as the medical examiner did, undetermined, and could not rule out suicide; the prosecutor asked whether he was telling the jury for the first time that he leans toward suicide, according to NBC10. He acknowledged that a broken hyoid bone is consistent with strangulation, that a hanging can be arranged after death, and that if the totality of the evidence pointed to homicide there would be no medical evidence to contradict that. He also conceded that Wednesday was the first time he saw or touched the ligature in person, which he said changed nothing, and that he relied on first responders’ observations. With questioning running late, the judge and lawyers agreed to finish within about 30 minutes. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 3:50 p.m., November 4. Defense pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew gave his opinion that the cause of Birchmore’s death was hanging and the manner undetermined, saying it is not good practice to guess on manner of death, NBC10 Boston reported. Asked whether, given the undetermined manner, the autopsy findings favor suicide, he said yes; prosecutors objected and moved to strike, but the judge allowed the answer, according to NBC10. He testified that he saw no scratch marks consistent with fingernails and no evidence of manual strangulation, that journal entries about suicide are very important to a pathologist’s investigation, and that he has testified for the prosecution in the past. He also said he had never been part of an in-person meeting like the one in this case among the FBI, an ER doctor and others. Cross-examination by prosecutors was beginning. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 3:35 p.m., November 4. Defense pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew testified that Birchmore’s hyoid bone fracture could have happened after her death, NBC10 Boston reported. He said the fracture was consistent with a seated hanging, that scientific journals show hyoid fractures can occur in seated hangings in people under 40, and that, given the lack of hemorrhaging at the site, the strap’s buckle could have contributed and the fracture could have been postmortem, according to NBC10. Looking at an autopsy photo, he said the ligature injury indicates the strap was placed while she was alive, and that there were no other marks or scrapes below the furrow, which was consistent with how her body was found. He said a body can convulse in a seated or partial hanging, though without video no one knows what happened, and that families often express disbelief about a loved one’s suicide. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 3:25 p.m., November 4. MassLive and WHDH also reported that Farwell will not testify. MassLive quoted him as telling the judge, “At this time, I would not like to testify,” and reported that he confirmed he discussed the decision with his lawyers; NBC10 quoted him as saying, “At this time I elect not to testify.” Chief Judge Casper has given Farwell until the moment the defense formally rests to change his mind, MassLive reported. MassLive also reported that Loper told jurors he saw at least one instance in which Birchmore’s phone did not record steps even though she was moving, a point aimed at the government’s evidence that her phone recorded steps at 9:40 p.m. on February 1, 2021, and never again. Dr. Thomas Andrew was still on the stand mid-afternoon. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 2:50 p.m., November 4. After the lunch break, the defense called its final expected witness, forensic pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew, who served 20 years as New Hampshire’s chief medical examiner, also worked in New York, has performed about 5,800 to 6,000 autopsies and now runs a forensic pathology consulting business, NBC10 Boston reported. He said he reviewed the initial autopsy and the hyoid bone removed from Birchmore’s neck, and he walked jurors through the position of her body, the angle of her head and how her leg was bent in the seated position, noting that the body had begun to decompose, according to NBC10. He then went through crime scene photos and an X-ray of her skull. As of 2:50 p.m. NBC10 had not reported his conclusions, and the defense had not rested. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 1:40 p.m., November 4. WCVB also reported that Farwell will not testify. Chief Judge Casper then laid out Friday’s closing arguments: the prosecution goes first with 75 minutes, the defense gets 90 minutes, and the prosecution gets another 15 minutes for rebuttal, NBC10 Boston reported. The defense argued that prosecutors should not be allowed to tell the jury there was no search for suicide methods if some laptop data was lost. Prosecutors said there is no evidence any data is missing, and the judge said she had heard nothing about gaps in searches, according to NBC10. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 1:20 p.m., November 4. Farwell will not testify. Matthew Farwell has chosen not to testify in his own defense, NBC10 Boston reported. While the jury was at lunch, Chief Judge Denise Casper asked his lawyers whether they had discussed the decision with him, and they said he had decided not to testify. The judge then questioned Farwell directly. Asked whether he understood, he said, “Yes, I do,” and asked for his decision, he said, “At this time I elect not to testify,” according to NBC10. The defense is expected to call its final witness, pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew, before resting. Closing arguments are expected Friday. Prosecutors cannot comment on his decision, and the jury cannot treat it as evidence of guilt. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 1:15 p.m., November 4. Judge denies defense request for a lost-evidence instruction. With Loper finished and the jury at lunch, the defense argued that investigators were grossly negligent with the digital evidence, citing lost laptop data, missing backups, reconnecting the laptop to WiFi and late extractions, and that they saw the laptop on February 4, 2021, but did not take it until February 9, NBC10 Boston reported. Prosecutors said no evidence was lost through negligence: the laptop was not found until more than seven days after Birchmore’s death, so some data would have been overwritten before investigators had it, and its hard drive crashed, according to NBC10. Chief Judge Denise Casper said she did not think the prosecution had shown bad faith regarding the laptop, and certainly not gross negligence, and declined to give the spoliation instruction the defense sought, NBC10 reported. That kind of instruction can tell jurors they may infer that lost evidence would have been unfavorable to the side that lost it. The jury will not sit Thursday, when the judge will go over exhibits with both sides. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 1 p.m., November 4. Prosecutors also had Loper confirm that Birchmore made phone calls on the afternoon and evening of February 1, 2021, including a 25-minute call at 8:29 p.m., and walk through her phone’s record of that night: it last locked at 9:13 p.m., Farwell arrived at 9:14, her phone recorded its last steps at 9:40, and Farwell left after that, NBC10 Boston reported. On redirect, Loper testified that her laptop was not recovered until February 9, 2021, eight days after her death, and that its data changed in that time in ways that cannot be known, according to NBC10. WCVB reported that the two sides had fought before trial over what parts of Loper’s testimony would be allowed, and that the defense could rest as early as Wednesday afternoon. Dr. Thomas Andrew is expected to be the final defense witness. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, noon, November 4. On cross-examination after the morning break, Loper acknowledged that he went through thousands of messages that were on Birchmore’s devices but not on Farwell’s phone, NBC10 Boston reported. He said Farwell gave his personal phone to State Police with no messages to Birchmore on it, even though her phone showed tens of thousands of exchanges between them, according to NBC10. He also acknowledged that newer technology for examining Apple Watches was available when he reviewed Birchmore’s watch than existed at the time of the original State Police investigation. As of noon, the defense had not rested and there was no report on whether Farwell will testify. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 11:15 a.m., November 4. Loper testified that the initial investigators did not use best practices in preserving Birchmore’s MacBook Pro, NBC10 Boston reported. He said they should have isolated it from WiFi instead of booting it up and connecting it, because using a device can overwrite data such as cached photos. He said he understands the initial extraction of the laptop was lost, that he had to work from an extraction done months later and a PDF report from years later, and that he cannot determine what was on the computer when the first extraction was done, according to NBC10. He also said the laptop was turned on several times while in State Police possession and that her phone last locked at 9:13 p.m. on February 1, 2021. Court took its morning break at 11:10 a.m. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 10:55 a.m., November 4. Loper testified that Birchmore’s iPhone 12 held 106 cached items from the morning of February 1, 2021, including images of a purple ribbon cached at 7:48 and 7:49 a.m. and a search for the meaning of a purple ribbon, NBC10 Boston reported. He said she typed the full phrase “what color is the suicide ribbon” at 7:50 a.m., according to NBC10. He also said he compared the timing of the lobby surveillance video with activity on her phone, and that on February 1 she texted nine people and two responded. As of late morning the defense had not rested and there was no report on whether Farwell will testify. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 4, 2026.

Update, 10:10 a.m., November 4. The defense called digital forensics expert Daniel Loper on Wednesday morning, NBC10 Boston reported. He testified that he reviewed both phones and devices and a large amount of surveillance footage, that Birchmore sent far more text messages than Farwell sent back, including on Facebook Messenger and WhatsApp, and that Farwell had 46 blocked numbers on his iPhone 11, one of them Birchmore’s. He said Birchmore was not blocked on February 1, 2021, because the two exchanged texts that day, according to NBC10. The defense is expected to rest Wednesday after Loper and pathologist Dr. Thomas Andrew, and Farwell must decide before then whether to testify, NBC10 and Boston 25 reported. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 3, 2026.

Update, 1:15 p.m., November 3. The defense called DNA expert Dr. Maher Noureddine on Tuesday. He testified about how evidence can be contaminated and how DNA from several people can be found in the same place, that many test results for seminal fluid were inconclusive, and that the strap found near Birchmore was not tested for skin cells, WCVB reported. On cross-examination by prosecutor Elizabeth Riley, he acknowledged that he is not a forensic DNA analyst, does not work in a lab, and did not test any of the evidence himself but interpreted others’ results, NBC10 Boston reported. Riley asked about DNA on the strap after Birchmore’s own; Noureddine called the next profile a trace sample, while the government argued it was higher than the FBI considers trace, according to NBC10. The defense then called Angi Christensen, a forensic anthropologist who worked for the FBI until 2025. The judge said the defense could rest Wednesday, there will be no court Thursday, and closing arguments are expected Friday, with 90 minutes for each side, WCVB reported. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 3, 2026.

Update, November 3. The defense called three witnesses Monday to rebut the government’s main expert, Dr. William Smock, MassLive reported. Forensic anthropologist Dr. Heather Garvin testified that the fracture of Birchmore’s hyoid bone does not prove strangulation. “There is nothing to indicate one mechanism or another, you cannot say,” she said, according to WHDH; MassLive reported she said her review of studies showed such fractures are possible in people under 40, in seated hangings and when the bone is not fused. On cross-examination, prosecutor Elizabeth Riley got Garvin to agree that none of the studies identify a case of a fractured hyoid in a seated hanging in someone that young, both outlets reported. Dr. William Ralston, Kentucky’s chief medical examiner, testified that Smock has never worked for his office in the decade Ralston has been chief and that his only role there is an unpaid one providing preventive treatment to employees, MassLive reported. Alicia McCarthy, a Thomas College professor, questioned Smock’s use of modeling clay to compare the strap’s clasp with an injury on Birchmore’s chest and said she was “on the fence” about whether the strap caused it, according to MassLive. On Tuesday the defense planned to call DNA expert Dr. Maher Noureddine and FBI forensic anthropologist Angi Christensen, then rest Wednesday after medical examiner Dr. Thomas Andrew and digital forensics expert Daniel Loper, MassLive reported. Closing arguments are expected Friday, with deliberations to follow, MassLive and WHDH reported. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, November 2, 2026.

Update, November 2, 2026, morning. The trial enters its final week. Three more defense witnesses are expected Monday, and the defense aims to finish its case by midweek, which could put closing arguments as early as Friday, WCVB reported. MassLive reported the three are forensic anthropologist Dr. Heather Garvin, who defense attorney Kimberly Stevens indicated reached a different conclusion than government expert Dr. William Smock; Dr. Alicia McCarthy, offered as an expert on pattern imprint injuries; and Dr. Bill Ralston, Kentucky’s chief medical examiner, testifying as a fact witness. MassLive said jurors are expected to hear closing arguments and begin deliberating Friday. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, October 30, 2026.

Update, October 30, 2026. Day 14: defense psychiatrist Dr. Melissa Piasecki testified that losing Farwell could have been “catastrophic” for Birchmore, NBC10 reported. Judge Denise Casper expects the jury to get the case Friday, November 6, and Farwell is not listed as a defense witness, according to NBC10. Full day 14 coverage and next week’s schedule.

Update, October 29, 2026. Days 12 and 13 (October 28 and 29): the government rested after FBI digital forensics expert Jessica Hyde’s phone timeline; the defense opened with a 2017 suicide-attempt report, moved for acquittal under Rule 29, and called Birchmore’s former boyfriend and medical examiner’s office witnesses. Full recap.

Update, October 28, 2026.

Update, October 28, 2026: Day 11 (October 27): William Farwell testified that Birchmore texted him the relationship with his brother began “when I was 15,” and prosecution expert Dr. William Smock testified she was strangled and the scene was altered. Read the day 11 coverage. Prosecutors were expected to rest on October 28.

Update, October 27, 2026. Day 10 (October 26): the medical examiner who first ruled the death a suicide testified she had limited information from police, and William Farwell, the defendant’s twin, testified under a grant of immunity about his own relationship with Birchmore.

Update, October 23, 2026. Day 9 of testimony, October 23, 2026, a half day: Birchmore’s longtime therapist, Diala Alkhalil, testified that she saw Birchmore on January 31, 2021, and saw no sign of suicidal thoughts or plans. On cross-examination she agreed suicidal thoughts can increase when patients begin taking antidepressants. Friend Lindsey Crean testified that Birchmore said Farwell told her “You are asking too much of me” when she said he only had to stop by on holidays, and acknowledged a message Birchmore sent her about nine months earlier about wanting to kill herself, the Boston Herald, Boston 25 News, WCVB and 7News reported. Boston 25 reported that closing arguments could come the first week of November. Details are in our day 9 post.

Update, October 22, 2026. Day 8 of testimony, October 22, 2026: the father of Birchmore’s unborn child, a former Army recruiter, testified under an immunity agreement that Birchmore told him the baby “was not and could not be” his and named Farwell as the father. A State Police crime lab analyst testified that Farwell’s DNA was found on the strap around Birchmore’s neck, and three women who had affairs with Farwell from 2012 to 2016 testified that he never wore a mask with them, the Boston Globe, NBC10 Boston, WCVB and CBS Boston reported. Details are in our day 8 post.

Update, October 21, 2026. Day 7 of testimony, October 21, 2026: Stoughton Detective Sandra Barrett testified that Farwell told her in late January 2021 that he was having problems with a woman other than his wife and believed the problem was “going to take care of itself.” Detective Daniel Barber testified that Farwell told him he had to “put crazy back in the bag.” Jurors also heard a forensic psychologist on grooming in general terms, a State Police forensic scientist, and friends of Birchmore’s about the pregnancy, as reported by the Boston Globe, NBC10 Boston and Boston.com. The testimony is covered in our day 7 post.

Update, October 20, 2026. Day 6 (October 20): a Stoughton police dispatcher testified that Farwell told him never to talk about a January 20, 2021 call that referred to his relationship with Birchmore’s friend, and Birchmore’s OB/GYN testified she saw no signs of suicidal thinking but agreed on cross that Zoloft can cause suicidal thoughts. Full recap in our day 6 post

Update, October 20, 2026. Day 5 of testimony (October 19): FBI Special Agent Heidi Kelsch testified on cross-examination that a paternity test identified an Army recruiter, not Farwell, as the father of Birchmore’s unborn child, and Chief Judge Casper ordered the government to remove the trial exhibits it had posted online. Full account: Farwell trial day 5

Update, October 16, 2026. Trial day 4 (October 16): FBI examiner Christopher Beckstrom testified that an iPhone linked to Farwell was used on February 9, 2021 to search “can you revoke consent in massachusetts,” and that Birchmore’s phone was last unlocked at 9:13 p.m. on February 1, 2021. On cross, he agreed Birchmore searched “what color is the suicide ribbon” that evening. Our day 4 recap.

Update, October 15, 2026. Day 3 of testimony, October 15: Birchmore’s friend Lesley Davis, Chief Donna McNamara on the January 20, 2021 call, and Trooper Nicholas Guarino on the limited 2021 search of Farwell’s phone. Our day 3 report.

Update, October 14, 2026.

Day 2 (October 14): Trooper Matthew Dunne testified no suicide note was found at the scene and described the unrecorded parking lot interview with Farwell; on cross, the defense showed him handwritten notes from Birchmore’s belongings, including one he said appears to be a suicide note dated 2017. Toxicologist Alicia Zimmerman and Stoughton Sgt. Robert Kuhn followed. Full day 2 recap.

Update, October 14, 2026. Day 2 of testimony is under way. Massachusetts State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne returned to the stand and testified that no suicide note was found in the apartment, NBC10 Boston and MassLive reported. According to NBC10, jurors were shown an ultrasound photo from Birchmore's refrigerator and a necklace that was later found broken at the scene, and Dunne said a camouflage duffel bag was missing a strap that appeared to be the ligature. Witnesses expected next include Birchmore's friend Leslie Davis, school resource officer Robert Kuhn, State Police crime lab toxicologist Alicia Zimmerman, and Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara. Day 1 recap: first officer said it “appears to be a suicide”. Farwell is presumed innocent.

Update, October 13, 2026.

Update, October 13, 2026 (evening): Six witnesses testified on the first day: Stoughton Detective Heather Cheever, former Sharon assistant principal Cheryl Carlson, property manager Erin Porter, Canton Officer Ensley Cotard (who said he told supervisors it “appears to be a suicide” and saw no note), maintenance supervisor Carlos Verissimo, and State Police Trooper Matthew Dunne, who returns Wednesday. The parties also filed a toxicology stipulation (ECF No. 349). Full witness-by-witness recap.

Update, October 13, 2026. Update, October 13, 2026: Testimony began Tuesday with Stoughton police Detective Heather Cheever, who said she was a mentor to Birchmore. Late Monday the defense answered both weekend government motions. It says Trooper Matthew Dunne told prosecutors in September that Birchmore’s journal entry was “absolutely a suicide note” and that he thought the mask meant Farwell was hiding an affair. It also says the “gushing blood” quote comes from a recorded phone call, and defense counsel apologized for saying “any one of you.” Read what the defense filed.

Update, October 12, 2026.

Update, October 12, 2026. Over the holiday weekend prosecutors filed two motions. One asks Judge Casper to let three women testify about alleged affairs with Farwell, and that he never wore a mask or disguise with them, to rebut the defense explanation that he wore a mask on February 1 to hide an affair; what the motion says and the Rule 404(b) question. The other asks for curative instructions, arguing the defense misstated jury unanimity and the federal-officer element and referred to texts the government says do not exist; the details. The defense has not yet responded and the judge has not ruled. Testimony begins Tuesday.

Update, October 10, 2026.

October 10, 2026: CBS Boston reported the defense told jurors Farwell went to Birchmore’s apartment to break up with her and told her the baby was not his. What that concession means, and the evidence rule that decides whether jurors hear his explanation.

Update, October 9, 2026.

Also October 9: Our full report on both opening statements and what the government has to prove.

Update, October 9, 2026.

Update, October 9, 2026, afternoon. A jury of 10 men and six women, 12 jurors and four alternates, was sworn in Friday morning, WHDH and NBC10 Boston reported, and both sides delivered opening statements before noon. Assistant U.S. Attorney Torey Cummings told jurors Farwell began a sexual relationship with Birchmore when she was 15 and he was 27, that Birchmore was excited about her pregnancy and had told some 80 people, and that Farwell, knowing what she could reveal, strangled her with a duffel bag strap and staged her death as a suicide; jurors were shown surveillance images of Farwell entering her building, NBC10 reported. For the defense, attorney Kimberly Stevens opened with “Matthew Farwell did not kill Sandra Birchmore,” and argued Birchmore died by suicide, pointing to her history of suicidal thoughts, a search for “What color is the suicide ribbon?” and texts the day before her death saying she was stressed and could not sleep, according to NBC10 and WHDH. Opening statements are not evidence. Testimony begins Tuesday, October 13, from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.; there is no court Monday. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, October 9, 2026.

Update, October 9, 2026. The jury was not finalized Thursday. Two groups of about 40 prospective jurors were questioned one at a time on follow-ups to the 17-page, 52-question survey, including whether suicide had touched their lives, NBC10 Boston reported. One woman was excused after saying she had followed the Karen Read trial closely and questioned police work in that case, knowing some investigators also worked this one. Judge Casper said peremptory challenges will be exercised Friday morning, the panel of 12 jurors and four alternates will be set, and opening statements will follow, possibly with some witness testimony before court ends at 1 p.m. There is no court Monday for the holiday, and the trial is expected to last about five weeks. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, October 8, 2026.

Update, October 8, 2026, morning. Jury selection resumed Thursday for a third day with the narrowed pool, and the first jurors could be seated today, NBC10 Boston and WHDH reported. If the panel is complete, Judge Casper has scheduled opening statements for Friday, October 9. Because Monday is a federal holiday, testimony would then begin Tuesday, October 13, NBC10 reported. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, October 7, 2026.

Update, October 7, 2026, evening. By the afternoon session the two sides had agreed to excuse 116 of the 411 prospective jurors, NBC10 Boston reported, and WCVB reported that 40 people will return to the Moakley courthouse Thursday for further questioning. Screening of the large pool was moved to an auditorium, WHDH reported. Judge Casper told the pool the trial is expected to last about five weeks, into the second week of November, according to Boston 25 News. WCVB also reported that the judge has allowed a new motion about an unnamed witness to be filed under seal, and that the April 28 detention hearing transcript shows prosecutors arguing Farwell had attended a Massachusetts State Police homicide conference that taught detectives how to investigate hanging deaths. Those are the government’s arguments, not findings. No jurors have been seated. Farwell has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.

Update, October 7, 2026.

Update, October 7, 2026, afternoon. Of 411 prospective jurors who filled out questionnaires, the two sides have agreed to disqualify 102, NBC10 Boston reported. No jurors have been seated. The remaining pool returns Thursday, when the lawyers will make final choices for the 16 seats, 12 jurors and four alternates.

Update, October 7, 2026.

Update, October 7, 2026. No jurors were chosen on the first day of selection, WCVB reported; Judge Casper wants 12 jurors and 4 alternates and told both sides to be ready to open as soon as Friday, with 45 minutes each. In a filing late Monday the defense said its digital forensics expert, Daniel Loper, would testify that Birchmore’s laptop was powered on or off at 9:41 p.m. on the day prosecutors say she was killed, and that Farwell had blocked her from contacting his iPhone. Prosecutors are trying for a second time to exclude Loper. A transcript of Farwell’s April 28 detention hearing, attached to a prosecution filing, shows prosecutors arguing that he wrote a goodbye letter to a friend after Dr. Michael Baden’s 2024 report called the death a homicide. Farwell is presumed innocent.

Update, October 7, 2026.

Update, October 7, 2026. The trial will not be livestreamed or photographed. Why federal Rule 53 bars cameras, and how to follow the trial.

Update, October 6, 2026.

Update, October 6, 2026. Jury selection began Tuesday morning with two pools filling out questionnaires, which the court said will not be made public, NBC10 Boston reported. Individual questioning is set for Thursday and opening statements are scheduled for Friday, October 9. No cameras are allowed in federal court.

Update, October 5, 2026.

Update, October 5, 2026. Judge Casper denied the renewed venue motion on October 1. Jury selection begins Tuesday, October 6, with openings possible Friday, October 9. Prosecutors re-searched Farwell’s phone after the defense said his 2021 consent covered the whole device, and the defense disclosed that State Police lost the raw data from Birchmore’s laptop in 2024. Full trial-eve report.

Update, September 30, 2026. Jury selection in the Farwell trial will begin Tuesday, October 6, a day later than scheduled, because other jury trials were already set to start Monday, Judge Denise Casper said, according to NBC10 Boston. The renewed venue motion is pending.

Update, September 29, 2026. September 28: Farwell filed a supplemental motion to transfer venue out of Massachusetts (Doc. 287), six days before jury selection; the government opposes and the court denied his first venue motion January 23. What it says and why transfer is unlikely.

Update, September 22, 2026. Pretrial rulings are in. At the September 17 final pretrial conference Chief Judge Casper allowed the government’s Rule 804(b)(6) forfeiture-by-wrongdoing motion, denied six defense motions in limine, and granted one, barring the FBI from presenting text messages as audio narration. A motion to exclude the expert testimony of Daniel Loper remains under advisement with a supplement due September 28, and a revised disputed exhibit list is due September 30. We read the docket and set out every ruling in this breakdown.

Update, September 21, 2026. Judge Casper has denied the defense motions to exclude Birchmore’s handwritten diary entries and to bar her doctor, her counselor, and her family and friends from testifying to their surprise at a suicide finding. The judge ruled that testimony “is not being offered as an opinion as to Ms. Birchmore’s cause of death but as to the state of mind of these treatment providers for actions they took or did not take.” Trial begins October 5 at 9 a.m. at the Moakley Courthouse (Boston Herald, September 21).

Update, September 18, 2026. A full preview of the trial, drawn from the superseding indictment, is in Matthew Farwell is not charged with murder. He is charged with killing a witness under 18 U.S.C. § 1512, which changes what the government must prove.

Update, September 18, 2026. Judge Casper has ruled that Birchmore’s journals, texts and social media posts are admissible. The hearsay doctrines behind that ruling, including forfeiture by wrongdoing, are explained in our report. Jury selection begins the first week of October.

Updated September 12, 2026. This page is the standing record of United States v. Farwell, the federal murder prosecution of former Stoughton police detective Matthew Farwell in the 2021 death of Sandra Birchmore. Jury selection begins October 5 in Boston before Chief Judge Denise J. Casper. The pretrial conference is September 17 and final witness lists are due September 21. This page will be updated at each stage.

The case in one paragraph

Sandra Birchmore was 23 and eight to ten weeks pregnant when she died in her Canton apartment in early February 2021. The state medical examiner ruled it a suicide. Three and a half years later, in August 2024, federal prosecutors charged Farwell with strangling her and staging the scene, alleging he had groomed her from the age of 15 through the Stoughton Police Explorers program, had sex with her while she was a minor and while he was on duty, and killed her to stop her from reporting it. He has pleaded not guilty. The defense says she died by her own hand.

Why it is a federal case

Murder is ordinarily a state crime. This one is in federal court because of the theory: that Farwell killed Birchmore to prevent her from communicating with law enforcement about a federal offense, which is the crime of killing a witness under the federal witness-tampering statute. That theory is also why the grooming allegations are not background but an element. The government has to prove not only that Farwell killed her but why.

On October 28, 2025, a superseding indictment added a second count for the death of her unborn child. On December 9, 2025, the government filed notice that “the Attorney General of the United States has directed the government not to seek the death penalty in this case.” The maximum on conviction is life.

The people

  • Sandra Birchmore, 23 at her death, a former Stoughton Police Explorer.
  • Matthew Farwell, former Stoughton detective, 27 when the indictment says he first had sex with Birchmore at 15. Held without bail since his arrest; the judge cited “very strong, if not overwhelming” evidence.
  • William Farwell, his twin brother and a former Stoughton officer, one of three officers a Stoughton internal investigation found had inappropriate relationships with Birchmore. He is not charged. Reports this week indicate he may be called as a witness.
  • Chief Judge Denise J. Casper, United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts.

Timeline

  • 2010 to 2016. Birchmore participates in the Stoughton Police Explorers Academy, where Farwell volunteers. The indictment alleges sexual contact beginning when she was 15.
  • December 2020. She tells Farwell she is pregnant.
  • January 20, 2021. A friend calls Stoughton police to report the relationship.
  • February 1, 2021. Birchmore dies in her Canton apartment. The medical examiner rules suicide.
  • 2022. A Stoughton internal investigation finds three officers, including both Farwell brothers, had inappropriate relationships with her. All leave the department. No charges.
  • August 2024. Federal grand jury indicts Matthew Farwell for killing a witness. He is arrested and held.
  • October 28, 2025. Superseding indictment adds the unborn-child count.
  • December 9, 2025. Government declines to seek the death penalty.
  • January 23, 2026. Casper denies the defense motion to move the trial to Rhode Island: “Farwell has not met the high burden of demonstrating that pretrial publicity would prevent him from receiving a fair trial in this District.”
  • March 9, 2026. Motion to dismiss the indictment denied.
  • August 5, 2026. Prosecutors file a witness list of about 50, including roughly a dozen experts.
  • September 1, 2026. Pretrial evidentiary hearing. Casper rules the defense may introduce Birchmore’s mental health history and suicidal ideation, and that prosecutors may call her a “victim.” Rulings on her journal entries, texts and the government’s expert witnesses taken under advisement.
  • September 17. Pretrial conference.
  • September 11 and 12. Government (68 names) and defense (97 names) witness lists filed, docket entries 259 and 260.
  • September 21. Deadline for final witness lists.
  • October 5. Jury selection. The trial is expected to run about twenty days.

The evidence fight

The trial will turn on two questions of proof, and the September 1 hearing showed where each side is weakest.

Homicide or suicide. The government’s medical case rests on Dr. William Smock, a strangulation expert who concluded homicide from a clasp-shaped imprint on her neck and a fractured neck bone, and on Dr. Michael Baden. The defense has challenged the reliability of both, arguing the findings are consistent with hanging. Casper has not yet ruled on the challenges. If she excludes or limits Smock, the government’s case is the circumstantial one: Farwell’s presence at the apartment, the phone and door evidence, and motive. If she admits him, the trial is a battle of forensic pathologists.

Motive and grooming. Dr. Lisa Rocchio, a forensic psychologist, would testify about grooming. Casper indicated she would allow “at least some” of that testimony, saying the disputes seemed “more suitable for cross-examination, as opposed to exclusion.” The defense theory, set out in its filings, is that the relationship was consensual by the time of her death and that Birchmore, with a documented history of suicidal thoughts, killed herself. Casper has allowed that history in. The government will answer that a pregnant woman who had just told the father, and whose friend had just reported him, had every reason to live and that the man she named had every reason to silence her.

The journals. Birchmore kept handwritten journals. Whether they come in, and under which hearsay exception, is the ruling still pending that could matter most. They are her own account of the relationship in her own words.

Update, September 12: the witness lists are in

Both sides filed their witness lists ahead of the September 21 deadline. The government’s list, docket entry 259, was filed September 11; Farwell’s, entry 260, was filed September 12. Independent court reporter Grant Smith Ellis posted images of both filings and a comparison: 31 names appear on both lists, 37 on the government’s only, and 66 on the defense’s only, for 68 government witnesses and 97 defense witnesses in all. The filings list names without roles.

Among the names on the government’s list are its experts Dr. William Smock, Dr. Michael Baden and Dr. Lisa Rocchio; Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara; State Police investigators John Fanning and Michael Lank; and William Farwell, the defendant’s twin brother, and his wife Angela. The defense list includes Dr. Mindy Hull, the state’s chief medical examiner, whose office ruled the death a suicide in 2021, and Kevin Albert, the former Canton police officer whose name figured in the Karen Read case. Ellis noted that Robert Devine, Farwell’s former supervisor at Stoughton, and Brian Tully, the State Police supervisor of the investigators, are not on the government’s list. A witness list is a disclosure, not a promise; either side may call fewer than it names.

What to watch

  • September 17. Rulings on the experts and the journals may issue at or before the conference.
  • September 21. The final witness lists. Whether William Farwell appears on either is the question being asked.
  • October 5. Jury selection in a case Casper has already found can be tried fairly in Massachusetts despite coverage she acknowledged was extensive.
Who was Sandra Birchmore?

A 23-year-old Canton woman and former Stoughton Police Explorer who died in her apartment in February 2021 while eight to ten weeks pregnant. Her death was initially ruled a suicide.

What is Matthew Farwell charged with?

Killing a witness under federal law, and, since October 2025, a second count for the death of her unborn child. He has pleaded not guilty. The government is not seeking the death penalty.

Why is the case in federal court?

Because the charge is that he killed her to prevent her from reporting a federal crime to law enforcement, which is a federal offense regardless of where the killing occurred.

What is the defense?

That Birchmore died by suicide, that the scene was not staged, and that the government’s strangulation experts are unreliable. The judge has allowed evidence of her mental health history.

When does the trial start?

Jury selection begins October 5, 2026 in Boston before Chief Judge Denise Casper. The trial is expected to last about twenty days.

Is Farwell in custody?

Yes. He has been held without bail since his August 2024 arrest.

Facts from the indictment and superseding indictment as reported by CBS Boston, NBC Boston, The Boston Globe and WHDH, 2024 through September 2026, and from the docket in United States v. Farwell, No. 1:24-cr-10259 (D. Mass.). September 1 hearing rulings as reported by The Boston Globe and NBC Boston. Matthew Farwell is presumed innocent, and nothing alleged by the government has been proved. General information about federal and Massachusetts law, not legal advice.

About·Editorial Standards·Contact·Privacy Policy·Terms of Use·Disclaimer
© 2026 Massachusetts Legal Resources
Massachusetts Legal Resources covers Massachusetts courts, criminal cases, new laws and ballot questions, and explains the law behind each story. Nothing on this site is legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.