Lindsay Clancy will be tried a second time for the murders of her three children. At a hearing in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, November 16, 2026, prosecutors said they intend to proceed with a jury trial, and the court set March 29, 2027 for the start, MassLive and NBC10 Boston reported. MassLive described March 29 as the start of jury selection.
Clancy, 36, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan at their Duxbury home on January 24, 2023. Her first trial ended in a mistrial on September 4 after the jury deadlocked, with a reported 11 to 1 split in favor of acquittal, WCVB reported. She has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent.
What happened in court today
- The prosecution’s announcement. Court opened with prosecutors saying they intend to proceed with a jury trial and were ready to pick a date, NBC10 reported.
- “The die has been cast.” Defense attorney Kevin Reddington said that, according to NBC10, and said he took the prosecution’s statement to mean first-degree murder. “I think you can read between the lines when they say the case is going to require a jury that it is an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments,” he said, as quoted by MassLive. NBC10 reported that the prosecution still had not formally said whether Clancy could face lesser charges.
- The fight over the date. Prosecutors said their first availability was in May, citing other cases, and suggested April 26, according to NBC10. Reddington suggested April. After what NBC10 called “heated back and forth” between the judge and the prosecution, Judge William F. Sullivan set March 29 over the prosecution’s objection, NBC10 reported.
- Next dates. NBC10 reported a status hearing on December 30 and a final pretrial hearing on March 18.
| Date | Event | Reported by |
|---|---|---|
| December 30, 2026 | Status hearing | NBC10 |
| March 18, 2027 | Final pretrial hearing | NBC10 |
| March 29, 2027 | Retrial begins (jury selection, per MassLive) | MassLive, NBC10 |
How we got here
- The two-week deadline. On November 2, Sullivan scheduled Monday’s hearing as a status or trial assignment conference, according to Boston.com.
- The DA’s review. Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz had said he would “be talking more” at Monday’s hearing, according to WCVB. Earlier this month he said his office was waiting on judicial decisions before making “a very methodical determination as to [what] we are going to do,” WHDH reported.
- Prosecutors hadn’t committed. At the November 2 hearing, asked whether the Commonwealth planned another trial, Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said, “We’re not at that point yet,” WCVB reported.
- The defense wants a trial. “I am not going to have this woman sit incarcerated for the next year or two or three,” defense attorney Kevin Reddington told Sullivan on November 2, according to Boston.com. “I want a trial, and I want it with you, and I want it this spring.” On timing, the outlets differ: NBC10 quoted him saying “I’d do March,” the timeframe Sullivan mentioned, while Boston.com reported the judge floated March and Reddington suggested April.
- “The ball is in Mr. Cruz’s court.” That’s what Reddington said on November 2, gesturing toward the district attorney in the gallery, Boston.com reported. Reddington has demanded to know whether prosecutors will retry Clancy on first-degree murder, reduce the charges, or resolve the case some other way.
Every way out has been closed at the trial court
| Defense request | Decided | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Required finding of not guilty (Rule 25(b)(2)) | October 1, 2026 | Denied |
| Dismiss the indictments on double jeopardy grounds | November 9, 2026 | Denied |
| Records about the holdout juror and questioning him under oath | November 9, 2026 | Denied |
“Now that we know that there is not a motion that’s going to dismiss the case either on double jeopardy grounds, 25b2, required finding, any of those, the path is wide open to a retrial,” Boston 25 News legal analyst Elyse Hershon said.
Prosecutors lost one too. Sullivan denied, without prejudice, their request for a gag order on the lawyers, and said they could renew it “if circumstances change and it can demonstrate that a prior restraint is necessary,” WCVB reported.
The defense says the SJC is next
The trial date may not be the last word. Martin G. Weinberg, an appellate lawyer on Clancy’s defense team, told Boston.com he expects an appeal to the Supreme Judicial Court in the “very near future.” Boston.com is the only outlet we found reporting that, and no appeal had been reported filed as of Monday. An SJC appeal could affect whether the March 29 date holds.
The holdout juror issue is over, for now
The defense spent weeks pressing claims about the lone juror who held out, including allegations that he failed to disclose an abuse prevention order on his questionnaire and used a cellphone in the jury room. Sullivan refused to order records or question him. “Because Clancy has failed to demonstrate that the requested evidence is relevant and material to her defense at any retrial of the murder indictment, the Court declines to exercise its discretion to order production,” he wrote, according to WCVB. “Nor can the Court perceive any valid justification for examining Juror Doe under oath at this point in the proceedings.”
The court has referred to him as Juror Doe, and so do we.
What a second trial would look like
- Same charges, new jury. A mistrial after a deadlock doesn’t end a case. Sullivan ruled the deadlock created the “manifest necessity” that allows a retrial, as we reported in our coverage of the November 9 rulings.
- Same defense. Clancy’s lawyers argued at the first trial that she was experiencing postpartum psychosis, had been incorrectly medicated, and was hearing voices, Boston 25 reported.
- Same judge, if the defense gets its wish. “I want it with you,” Reddington told Sullivan.
Frequently asked questions
Is Lindsay Clancy getting a new trial?
Yes. Prosecutors said on November 16, 2026 that they intend to proceed with a jury trial, and the retrial is set to begin March 29, 2027, MassLive and NBC10 reported.
Why was there a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case?
The jury deadlocked after seven days of deliberations, with a reported 11 to 1 split in favor of acquittal, according to WCVB. The judge declared a mistrial on September 4, 2026.
Can Lindsay Clancy be tried again after a hung jury?
Yes. Judge Sullivan ruled on November 9 that the deadlock created manifest necessity for the mistrial, so a retrial does not violate double jeopardy.
When is the Lindsay Clancy retrial?
March 29, 2027. NBC10 reported the judge chose it over the prosecution’s objection; prosecutors had suggested April 26.
Will Lindsay Clancy be retried on first-degree murder?
Her lawyer believes so. Reddington said the prosecution’s request for a jury trial was “an indirect comment” that the DA intends to proceed on the first-degree murder indictments. NBC10 reported prosecutors had not formally said whether she could face lesser charges.
Sources: MassLive, NBC10 Boston, WCVB, Boston 25 News, WHDH and Boston.com, November 16, 2026. Earlier rulings as reported in our prior coverage. General information, not legal advice.
