Nobody Was Hit When Boston Police Fired on Valentine’s Day. A Grand Jury Just Indicted Two Officers for Assault With a Dangerous Weapon

No one was hit when Boston police fired their guns during a Valentine's Day call in Dorchester. A grand jury has now indicted both officers.

Two Boston police officers have been indicted on charges of assault with a dangerous weapon for firing their guns during a call in Dorchester on Valentine’s Day. Nobody was hit. The indictments against Officers Rudolph “Rudy” Lewis and Jairo Polanco were unsealed Wednesday, November 18, 2026, MassLive and WCVB reported.

A grand jury returned the indictments on November 13, and prosecutors moved to keep them sealed, MassLive reported, citing court records. Each officer faces one count of assault with a dangerous weapon, a felony. The indictments say the officers committed an assault on a person identified by initials “by means of a dangerous weapon, to wit: handgun,” according to MassLive. Both officers are presumed innocent, and their lawyers say they fired in self-defense.

What happened on February 14

Here is what has been reported. None of it has been tested in court.

  • The call. Officers went to a home in Dorchester around 10:29 p.m. on February 14, MassLive reported. WCVB reported they were called to help a woman in distress on the second floor. MassLive reported that the department’s district journal shows a report of an aggravated assault at that address at that time.
  • The shots. WCVB reported that the officers are accused of firing gunshots through the woman’s home. Department spokesman Mark Marron told MassLive that an officer fired and no one was shot.
  • The woman. A person was detained at the scene but not arrested, and was taken to a hospital for an evaluation, Marron told MassLive. She is identified in the indictments only by initials. We are not naming her.
  • Leave. A source told WCVB’s 5 Investigates that the officers were placed on leave earlier this month, days before the indictment. The department did not explain the timing, WCVB reported.

What the officers’ lawyers say

“What people need to know is that a woman jabbed a knife toward my client’s face in close range. My client repeatedly ordered the woman to drop the knife. She refused. My client and his partner fired to defend themselves,” said Benjamin Megrian, who represents Lewis, in a statement reported by WCVB and MassLive. “The DA’s office seems to believe officers need to get stabbed in the face before they are allowed to react,” the statement continued, according to WCVB.

Megrian also told Boston 25 News he was “deeply concerned about the integrity of this investigation when the public and the media are learning about it before the charges have been unsealed,” MassLive reported. Reports that the officers had been indicted surfaced Tuesday, citing law enforcement sources, a day before the indictments were unsealed.

An attorney for Polanco called the indictments “a result of a deeply misguided decision by arm chair Monday morning quarterback prosecutors who aren’t concerned for the safety of police officers,” WCVB reported.

The Boston Police Patrolmen’s Association said it was “once again severely disappointed in the DA’s decision to indict our officers for doing their jobs.” Union president Larry Calderone said, “I’m told the alleged victim brandished a knife and put our officers in fear for their lives,” according to MassLive.

The Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office declined to comment to WCVB. The Boston Police Department did not respond to WCVB’s requests for comment.

The charge: assault with a dangerous weapon

The officers are charged under G.L. c. 265, § 15B(b), which reads in full: “Whoever, by means of a dangerous weapon, commits an assault upon another shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for not more than five years or by a fine of not more than one thousand dollars or imprisonment in jail for not more than two and one-half years.”

Two things about that charge explain why it fits a shooting where nobody was hurt.

  • No injury is required. Assault in Massachusetts does not require touching anyone. It covers an attempted battery and conduct that puts someone in reasonable fear of an imminent battery. A gunshot that misses can be an assault. If a bullet had hit someone, the charge would more likely have been assault and battery by means of a dangerous weapon, a separate offense.
  • A handgun is a dangerous weapon by definition. Some objects become dangerous weapons because of how they are used. A firearm is dangerous in itself, so prosecutors do not have to prove it was used in a way capable of causing serious injury.

Why a grand jury, when District Court could have heard it

Assault with a dangerous weapon is a felony with a five-year maximum, which means Boston Municipal Court could have tried it. Under G.L. c. 218, § 26, District Courts and the Boston Municipal Court share jurisdiction with the Superior Court over “all felonies punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for not more than five years.”

Prosecutors went to a grand jury instead, and an indictment puts the case in Suffolk Superior Court. A District Court judge can sentence someone to no more than two and a half years in a house of correction. Only Superior Court can impose the state prison term the statute allows. Bringing a police shooting to a grand jury also lets citizens decide whether charges are warranted. The DA’s office has not said why it went that route here.

The self-defense question

The officers’ defense is self-defense, and in a police case that question runs through the 2020 police reform law as well as the ordinary rules.

Under G.L. c. 6E, § 14(b), “A law enforcement officer shall not use deadly force upon a person unless de-escalation tactics have been attempted and failed or are not feasible based on the totality of the circumstances and such force is necessary to prevent imminent harm to a person and the amount of force used is proportionate to the threat of imminent harm.”

That sets out the questions a jury is likely to hear about:

  • Imminent harm. Was there a threat of harm right then? Lewis’s lawyer says a woman jabbed a knife toward his client’s face at close range.
  • De-escalation. Were de-escalation tactics tried and did they fail, or were they not feasible? Megrian says his client “repeatedly ordered the woman to drop the knife.”
  • Proportionality. Was firing a gun proportionate to the threat?

Under ordinary Massachusetts criminal law, once a defendant raises self-defense with enough evidence, the Commonwealth has to disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt. The officers don’t have to prove they acted in self-defense. Prosecutors have to prove they didn’t.

The body camera video

WCVB’s 5 Investigates asked Boston police for body camera footage in March and was denied. City Councilor Miniard Culpepper made a formal request for the video through a council information order known as a 17F, was also denied, and is now calling for its release. “I think the body cam footage doesn’t lie,” Culpepper told WCVB.

In the case against Officer Nicholas O’Malley, a judge impounded the body camera video at least until trial, WCVB reported in October. Whether the video in this case is released before trial is likely to be decided in Superior Court.

Not the first Boston officer charged this year

The indictments come months after Officer Nicholas O’Malley was charged with manslaughter in the fatal shooting of a carjacking suspect in Roxbury, MassLive noted. The union sharply criticized Suffolk District Attorney Kevin Hayden over that case and endorsed one of his opponents in his re-election bid this fall, MassLive reported. We covered O’Malley’s motion to dismiss and the 2020 law on shooting at fleeing cars.

MassLive reported that city payroll records show Polanco earned more than $218,000 in 2025 and Lewis roughly $185,000. It was not immediately clear when the officers would be arraigned.

Frequently asked questions

Which Boston police officers were indicted?

Officers Rudolph “Rudy” Lewis and Jairo Polanco, each on one count of assault with a dangerous weapon, according to indictments unsealed November 18, 2026, as reported by MassLive and WCVB.

Was anyone hurt in the Valentine’s Day shooting in Dorchester?

No. A Boston police spokesman told MassLive no one was shot.

Can you be charged with assault if no one was hurt?

Yes. Assault in Massachusetts does not require injury or contact. Firing a gun that misses can support a charge of assault with a dangerous weapon under G.L. c. 265, § 15B(b), which carries up to five years in state prison.

When can Massachusetts police use deadly force?

Under G.L. c. 6E, § 14(b), only when de-escalation has been tried and failed or isn’t feasible, the force is necessary to prevent imminent harm to a person, and it is proportionate to that threat.

Will the body camera video be released?

Not so far. Boston police denied requests from WCVB and from City Councilor Miniard Culpepper, according to WCVB.

Sources: MassLive and WCVB, November 17 and 18, 2026; G.L. c. 265, § 15B, c. 218, § 26 and c. 6E, § 14 as published by the Massachusetts Legislature. The woman at the home is not named. General information, not legal advice.

About·Editorial Standards·Contact·Privacy Policy·Terms of Use·Disclaimer
© 2026 Massachusetts Legal Resources
Massachusetts Legal Resources covers Massachusetts courts, criminal cases, new laws and ballot questions, and explains the law behind each story. Nothing on this site is legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.