Lindsay Clancy’s bid to stop her retrial is going to the full Supreme Judicial Court. On Thursday, November 19, 2026, Associate Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar wrote that after considering the defense petition, the Commonwealth’s opposition and the trial court’s November 9 order, review of Clancy’s petition by the full court is warranted, NBC10 Boston reported. Oral arguments are scheduled for January 2027, WCVB and NBC10 reported.
The filing also made public, for the first time, the handwritten notes the jury sent the judge before he declared a mistrial in September. Those notes are the center of the defense argument.
Clancy, 36, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan at their Duxbury home on January 24, 2023. She has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent. Her retrial remains scheduled for March 29, 2027.
The schedule the SJC set
| Date | Deadline |
|---|---|
| December 3, 2026 | Clancy’s brief due |
| December 17, 2026 | Commonwealth’s brief due |
| December 28, 2026 | Clancy’s reply brief, if any |
| December 30, 2026 | Status hearing in Plymouth Superior Court (set November 16) |
| January 2027 | Oral argument before the full SJC, unless the court orders otherwise |
| March 18, 2027 | Final pretrial hearing |
| March 29, 2027 | Retrial scheduled to begin |
The briefing dates and the January argument are from WCVB and NBC10. WCVB also reported that the parties must prepare an agreed statement of facts for the full court’s record. The December 30 and March 18 dates are as NBC10 reported them from the November 16 hearing.
The timing is tight. Briefing closes at the end of December, argument is in January, and the retrial is set for late March. The SJC would have to rule within about two months of argument for its decision to come before jury selection. Nothing reported so far says whether the trial date will move.
What the jury notes say
The first note from the foreperson read, according to WCVB:
“A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt. How should we proceed?”
A second note read, as WCVB transcribed it:
“Juror (blank) has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states. This is why we can not come to a unanimous decision.”
NBC10 quoted that second note slightly differently: “The juror has made statements, acknowledging doubt, but refused to apply that to the verdict.” The juror’s name is blanked out in the notes, and we do not name the juror.
The jury was split 11 to 1 in favor of acquittal, NBC10 reported, and jurors accused the holdout of not deliberating in good faith. The man who has identified himself in media interviews as the holdout juror has denied that he failed to follow the law, WCVB reported.
The defense argument, in one sentence
Clancy’s lawyers say that once the jury told the judge one juror would not apply the reasonable doubt instruction, Judge William F. Sullivan should have questioned the foreperson and the holdout to find out whether there was cause to remove him, and that declaring a mistrial without doing that was improper, according to NBC10 and WCVB.
If that is right, the consequence is large. A retrial after a mistrial is allowed only when the mistrial was a “manifest necessity.” If a judge declares a mistrial over the defendant’s objection when there was a reasonable alternative, double jeopardy can bar a second trial entirely. That is why the defense is asking the SJC to throw the case out, not just to delay it.
What the Commonwealth says
The Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office has filed an opposition urging the SJC to reject Clancy’s challenge and let the retrial go forward, WCVB reported. Sullivan already sided with the Commonwealth on November 9, ruling that the deadlock created the manifest necessity that allows a retrial, as we reported in our coverage of that ruling.
Retired judge Jim Barretto, speaking to WCVB, called the defense filing “massive, over 200 pages” and “extraordinarily well written,” but added: “my money would be: we’re going to see a second trial.”
How a case gets to the SJC before trial
Ordinarily, a defendant cannot appeal a trial judge’s ruling until after a verdict. Double jeopardy is an exception in practice, because the protection is against being tried at all, and that protection is lost if the only remedy comes after the second trial.
The SJC’s power to step in comes from G.L. c. 211, § 3, which gives it “general superintendence of all courts of inferior jurisdiction to correct and prevent errors and abuses therein if no other remedy is expressly provided.” Petitions under that statute go first to a single justice, who can decide them or send them to the full seven-member court. The reports we read do not cite the statute Clancy’s petition was filed under, but they describe exactly that path: a petition filed Monday, November 16, and a single justice ruling three days later that the full court should hear it.
Sending a case to the full court is not a ruling on the merits. It means the question is substantial enough that the whole court should decide it.
Where this leaves the retrial
- If the SJC rules for Clancy, the murder indictments could be dismissed and there would be no second trial.
- If the SJC rules for the Commonwealth, the retrial goes forward, and Sullivan’s November 9 ruling stands.
- If the SJC hasn’t ruled by late March, the trial court would have to decide whether to start jury selection while the appeal is pending. No outlet has reported how that would be handled.
Prosecutors told the court on November 16 that they need a jury for the retrial, which defense attorney Kevin Reddington took to mean the Commonwealth will again try her for first-degree murder. The DA’s office has not formally said what charges it will pursue.
Frequently asked questions
Is the SJC hearing Lindsay Clancy’s appeal?
Yes. On November 19, 2026, Associate Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar concluded that review by the full Supreme Judicial Court is warranted, NBC10 reported. Oral arguments are set for January 2027.
What is Lindsay Clancy’s SJC appeal about?
Double jeopardy. Her lawyers argue the judge improperly declared a mistrial without questioning the holdout juror after the jury reported that one member would not follow the reasonable doubt instruction, so a second trial would be unconstitutional.
What did the Lindsay Clancy jury notes say?
One note said a juror was “unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt.” Another said the juror had acknowledged doubt but refused to apply it to the verdict, according to WCVB and NBC10.
Is the Lindsay Clancy retrial still on for March 29?
Yes, as of November 19, 2026. The SJC’s January argument could affect that if the court rules for Clancy or hasn’t ruled by then.
When are the briefs due in the Clancy SJC appeal?
Clancy’s brief is due December 3, the Commonwealth’s December 17, and any reply December 28, according to WCVB and NBC10.
Sources: NBC10 Boston and WCVB, November 18 and 19, 2026; NBC10 Boston (Associated Press), November 16, 2026; G.L. c. 211, § 3 as published by the Massachusetts Legislature; earlier rulings as reported in our prior coverage. No juror is named. General information, not legal advice.
